Warm nights mean a renewed focus on balcony and porch safety
July 27, 2009
In 2003, 13 young adults were killed and 57 injured when an overcrowded and poorly constructed balcony collapsed during a party on Chicago’s north side. It was the deadliest porch accident in U.S. history.
Richard Pullano represents two of the families affected by this tragic accident. Witnesses say that prior to the accident, the porch looked like it was sturdy and “newly built.” City officials initially declared that there was “no indication of any substandard problems or insufficiencies with the porch.”
A closer investigation quickly revealed that the porch had been built without a permit and that basic building requirements had been ignored.
In the six years since this accident, awareness about balcony and porch safety has improved, and the City of Chicago and other municipalities have stepped up their inspections of these structures. Still, the potential for accidents persists. Harsh winters can compromise outdoor structures, particularly those made of wood. Most residents haven’t ventured out onto their balcony since last summer and may be unaware of any potential hazards.
Not that the average homeowner is qualified to detect many potential hazards — balconies and porches often appear structurally sound to the casual observer. Most deficiencies are only identified after professional and deliberate scrutiny. Moreover, the recent economic downturn may result in landlords and homeowners delaying important rehabilitation projects and other safety improvements.
The 2003 porch collapse was a preventable event. Unfortunately, until all landlords, homeowners, and municipalities recognize their obligations to ensure public safety, the possibility looms for a similar tragedy. As we continue to pursue justice for the victims and their families, we encourage people to take steps to make sure summer is safe and fun for everyone.